Ice and Water Roof Underlayment: What It Seals and Where It Belongs

Ice and water roof underlayment is a self adhering membrane of rubberized asphalt that bonds directly to the deck and closes tight around every nail driven through it. Felt and synthetic underlayment shed water that is running downhill. This membrane holds water that has stopped moving and is pressing up underneath the shingles, which is exactly what happens behind an ice dam.

Connecticut roofs get tested on that difference every winter. Our service area averages more than 40 inches of snow a year, and ice dam leaks sit among the most common roofing insurance claims in Hartford County.

What ice and water roof underlayment actually does

CertainTeed describes its WinterGuard membrane as a composite of asphalt and elastomeric polymers reinforced with a fiber glass sheet, and says the polymers keep the asphalt elastic and sticky all the way through, so the membrane “seals like a gasket around nails driven through it.”

A shingle roof puts thousands of nail holes through the underlayment. CertainTeed notes that felt underlayments can leak around the nails driven through them. Water moving downhill past a nail hole usually does no harm. Water standing on top of one does. GAF lists sealability around a nail, tested to ASTM D1970, among the pass criteria its StormGuard leak barrier meets.

Behind an ice dam the water is standing. Snowmelt runs down the slope, meets the frozen band over the cold eave, backs up into a shallow pond, and takes the lowest resistance path it can find. On a felt deck that path is a fastener. On a fully adhered membrane there is no path, because the asphalt has already closed around the shank. If you want the upstream half of this problem, we cover how ice dams form on Connecticut roofs separately.

How it differs from felt and synthetic underlayment

Layer How it attaches At a nail penetration Where it earns its keep
Asphalt saturated felt Nailed or capped to the deck Can leak around the fastener, per CertainTeed Secondary water shedding over the open field
Synthetic underlayment Nailed or capped to the deck Relies on the fastener staying above standing water Tear strength and long exposure during the job
Self adhering ice and water membrane Fully adhered to bare deck Closes around the shank as it is driven Eaves, valleys, penetrations, wall tie ins

Felt and synthetic are shedding layers. They assume water keeps moving and never gets a chance to sit.

Ice and water roof underlayment makes no such assumption, which is why it is the layer specified wherever water pools, backs up or gets pushed sideways by wind. CertainTeed is direct about the substitution limits too: two layers of its synthetic underlayment cemented together are not an equivalent to its waterproofing membrane for ice dam protection.

The membrane also costs more per square and takes longer to lay, so nobody sheets an entire roof in it without a reason. Choosing where it goes is the real decision, and it runs alongside the shingle and flashing choices on our roofing materials page.

Where the ice and water shield belongs

CertainTeed calls out the eaves, roof penetrations and valleys as the locations most likely to need a waterproofing underlayment, and recommends the membrane as concealed flashing around pipes, skylights, chimneys, sidewalls, dormers and roof transitions. GAF makes the same recommendation for its leak barrier at valleys, dormers, skylights, penetrations, flashings and transitions.

In a valley, CertainTeed specifies a minimum 36 inch width of membrane centered on the valley line, applied from the low point upward with sheets lapped 6 inches, upper sheet over lower. Valleys collect two roof planes worth of melt and freeze earliest, so they dam even when the eaves stay clear.

Chimneys and skylights are the other reliable leak sites, because ice piles up on the uphill side of anything that interrupts the slope. Ice and water roof underlayment goes on the deck first and the step and counter flashing goes over it.

That order matters. The metal stays the primary defense and the membrane is the backup, already sealed around its own fasteners. We hold a three star Velux installer rating and handle skylight installation with that sequence.

At a wall intersection, run the membrane up the vertical surface before the wall covering goes back, not just across the deck. Melt that runs down a sunny wall and refreezes at the roof plane is a dam that never touches the eave.

What the code says about ice barrier coverage

The International Residential Code, in section R905.1.2, requires an ice barrier in areas with a history of ice forming along the eaves and backing water up. It accepts either not fewer than two layers of underlayment cemented together or a self adhering polymer modified bitumen sheet in place of normal underlayment.

The International Residential Code then sets the extent. It requires the barrier to run from the lowest edge of all roof surfaces to a point not less than 24 inches inside the exterior wall line of the building. The code text as published by building departments adds that on roofs of 8 units vertical in 12 units horizontal or steeper, the barrier also runs not less than 36 inches measured along the slope from the eave edge.

Two details in that wording get misread on site. The measurement is horizontal, taken in plan view, not up the slope. And the reference point is the interior face of the exterior wall, not the gutter or the fascia.

Connecticut does not simply inherit that text unchanged. The Connecticut Department of Administrative Services put the 2022 Connecticut State Building Code into effect on October 1, 2022, and town building departments list it as built on the 2021 International Residential Code with Connecticut amendments. We are not going to state a Connecticut specific figure we cannot show you in the adopted amendments. Treat the code language above as the model baseline and confirm the requirement that applies to your address with your town building department before a permit is pulled.

Why one narrow course at the eave is not enough

Rolls come 36 inches wide, and the common shortcut is one course along the eave, fastened above the drip edge, done. On most houses that course stops short of the wall line the code measures from.

Work the geometry. The 24 inches is measured horizontally from inside the wall, so the distance up the slope is that 24 inches plus the overhang plus the wall thickness, all multiplied by the pitch. Fine Homebuilding ran the numbers for a 12 inch overhang on a 2×6 wall and got roughly 47 inches up the slope at a 6 in 12 pitch, about 50 inches at 8 in 12, and about 59 inches at 12 in 12. A single 36 inch course reaches none of those.

A deep overhang makes it worse in a way that surprises people. Every extra inch of soffit is an extra inch of horizontal run before the measurement even starts, so a 24 inch overhang pushes the required line a foot further up the roof than a 12 inch overhang on the same pitch.

Low slope roofs fail for a different reason. Water backed up behind a dam of a given thickness spreads much further up a shallow pitch than a steep one, because the deck rises so slowly away from the eave.

CertainTeed addresses this directly. In areas of severe icing, it says, the membrane must be applied at least up to the highest water level that might conservatively be expected from ice dams, and that level varies with climate, ventilation, insulation and roof slope. On a 3 in 12 porch roof under a heated wall, two courses is the floor. CertainTeed sets 2 in 12 as the minimum approved slope for its membrane and calls for full deck coverage below 4 in 12.

The vapor trap on an unvented assembly

Full deck coverage carries a cost that does not show up until a few winters later. CertainTeed states plainly that WinterGuard is a vapor retarder and that if it is applied over the entire roof, special care is needed to ensure sufficient ventilation beneath the deck to prevent condensation. GAF publishes a moisture vapor permeance of no more than 0.1 perms by ASTM E96 for its StormGuard leak barrier.

On a vented attic that is a non issue, because the air above the insulation is outdoor air and the sheathing stays near outdoor temperature. On an unvented cathedral assembly it is a live question. A near vapor tight layer sitting on the cold side of the sheathing gives moisture from inside the house nowhere to go, and the sheathing is where it condenses.

If your roof has no ventilation path, the assembly needs to be designed for that, with the insulation and air sealing doing the work. That is a question for whoever specifies the assembly, and it should be settled before anyone decides how much of the deck gets membrane.

Getting the detail right on your roof

Ask any roofer bidding your job three questions: how far up the slope the ice and water roof underlayment will run at the eaves, whether valleys get a full 36 inch width, and whether the membrane carries up the sidewalls and behind the chimney flashing. The answers tell you more about the bid than the shingle brand does.

Rising Star Roofing has been installing these details across Hartford County since 2007, as a GAF Master Elite certified and licensed Connecticut contractor, HIC.0703559. For a measured eave by eave plan on your roof, request a free roofing estimate or call 860 796 5668.

Scroll to Top